Does Your 3D Encoder Really Work? When Pretrain-SFT from 2D VLMs Meets 3D VLMs
Remarkable progress in 2D Vision-Language Models (VLMs) has spurred interest in extending them to 3D settings for tasks like 3D Question Answering, Dense Captioning, and Visual Grounding. Unlike 2D VLMs that typically process images through an image encoder, 3D scenes, with their intricate spatial structures, allow for diverse model architectures. Based on their encoder design, this paper categorizes recent 3D VLMs into 3D object-centric, 2D image-based, and 3D scene-centric approaches. Despite the architectural similarity of 3D scene-centric VLMs to their 2D counterparts, they have exhibited comparatively lower performance compared with the latest 3D object-centric and 2D image-based approaches. To understand this gap, we conduct an in-depth analysis, revealing that 3D scene-centric VLMs show limited reliance on the 3D scene encoder, and the pre-train stage appears less effective than in 2D VLMs. Furthermore, we observe that data scaling benefits are less pronounced on larger datasets. Our investigation suggests that while these models possess cross-modal alignment capabilities, they tend to over-rely on linguistic cues and overfit to frequent answer distributions, thereby diminishing the effective utilization of the 3D encoder. To address these limitations and encourage genuine 3D scene understanding, we introduce a novel 3D Relevance Discrimination QA dataset designed to disrupt shortcut learning and improve 3D understanding. Our findings highlight the need for advanced evaluation and improved strategies for better 3D understanding in 3D VLMs.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
cross-modal alignmentDense CaptioningQuestion AnsweringScene UnderstandingVisual GroundingSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
We Built a Fake News / Click Bait Filter: What Happened Next Will Blow Your Mind!
It is completely amazing! Fake news and {``}click baits{''} have totally invaded the cyberspace. Let us face it: everybody hates them for three simple reasons. Reason {\#}2 will absolutely amaze you. What these can achie…
Author ProfilingClickbait DetectionWord EmbeddingsWe Built a Fake News & Click-bait Filter: What Happened Next Will Blow Your Mind!
It is completely amazing! Fake news and click-baits have totally invaded the cyber space. Let us face it: everybody hates them for three simple reasons. Reason #2 will absolutely amaze you. What these can achieve at the …
Author ProfilingTask Specific Pruning with LLM-Sieve: How Many Parameters Does Your Task Really Need?
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being adopted for narrow tasks - such as medical question answering or sentiment analysis - and deployed in resource-constrained settings, a key question arises: how many …
Medical Question AnsweringQuantizationQuestion AnsweringSentiment AnalysisHow well does your sampler really work?
We present a new data-driven benchmark system to evaluate the performance of new MCMC samplers. Taking inspiration from the COCO benchmark in optimization, we view this task as having critical importance to machine learn…
Meta-LearningSanity Checks for Lottery Tickets: Does Your Winning Ticket Really Win the Jackpot?
There have been long-standing controversies and inconsistencies over the experiment setup and criteria for identifying the "winning ticket" in literature. To reconcile such, we revisit the definition of lottery ticket hy…