Dynamical Kinds and their Discovery
We demonstrate the possibility of classifying causal systems into kinds that share a common structure without first constructing an explicit dynamical model or using prior knowledge of the system dynamics. The algorithmic ability to determine whether arbitrary systems are governed by causal relations of the same form offers significant practical applications in the development and validation of dynamical models. It is also of theoretical interest as an essential stage in the scientific inference of laws from empirical data. The algorithm presented is based on the dynamical symmetry approach to dynamical kinds. A dynamical symmetry with respect to time is an intervention on one or more variables of a system that commutes with the time evolution of the system. A dynamical kind is a class of systems sharing a set of dynamical symmetries. The algorithm presented classifies deterministic, time-dependent causal systems by directly comparing their exhibited symmetries. Using simulated, noisy data from a variety of nonlinear systems, we show that this algorithm correctly sorts systems into dynamical kinds. It is robust under significant sampling error, is immune to violations of normality in sampling error, and fails gracefully with increasing dynamical similarity. The algorithm we demonstrate is the first to address this aspect of automated scientific discovery.
Code (1)
Tasks
scientific discoverySimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
CausalDynamics: A large-scale benchmark for structural discovery of dynamical causal models
Causal discovery for dynamical systems poses a major challenge in fields where active interventions are infeasible. Most methods used to investigate these systems and their associated benchmarks are tailored to determini…
Causal DiscoveryGraph ReconstructionUnsupervised Lexicon Discovery from Acoustic Input
We present a model of unsupervised phonological lexicon discovery{---}the problem of simultaneously learning phoneme-like and word-like units from acoustic input. Our model builds on earlier models of unsupervised phone-…
Language AcquisitionSpeech RecognitionDiscovering governing equation in structural dynamics from acceleration-only measurements
Over the past few years, equation discovery has gained popularity in different fields of science and engineering. However, existing equation discovery algorithms rely on the availability of noisy measurements of the stat…
Equation DiscoveryBody Discovery of Embodied AI
In the pursuit of realizing artificial general intelligence (AGI), the importance of embodied artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly apparent. Following this trend, research integrating robots with AGI has bec…
Causal InferenceInvestigating the effect of binning on causal discovery
Binning (a.k.a. discretization) of numerically continuous measurements is a wide-spread but controversial practice in data collection, analysis, and presentation. The consequences of binning have been evaluated for many …
Causal Discovery