Moderating the Mediation Bootstrap for Causal Inference
Mediation analysis is a form of causal inference that investigates indirect effects and causal mechanisms. Confidence intervals for indirect effects play a central role in conducting inference. The problem is non-standard leading to coverage rates that deviate considerably from their nominal level. The default inference method in the mediation model is the paired bootstrap, which resamples directly from the observed data. However, a residual bootstrap that explicitly exploits the assumed causal structure (X->M->Y) could also be applied. There is also a debate whether the bias-corrected (BC) bootstrap method is superior to the percentile method, with the former showing liberal behavior (actual coverage too low) in certain circumstances. Moreover, bootstrap methods tend to be very conservative (coverage higher than required) when mediation effects are small. Finally, iterated bootstrap methods like the double bootstrap have not been considered due to their high computational demands. We investigate the issues mentioned in the simple mediation model by a large-scale simulation. Results are explained using graphical methods and the newly derived finite-sample distribution. The main findings are: (i) conservative behavior of the bootstrap is caused by extreme dependence of the bootstrap distribution's shape on the estimated coefficients (ii) this dependence leads to counterproductive correction of the the double bootstrap. The added randomness of the BC method inflates the coverage in the absence of mediation, but still leads to (invalid) liberal inference when the mediation effect is small.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Causal InferenceMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Identification and multiply robust estimation in causal mediation analysis across principal strata
We consider assessing causal mediation in the presence of a post-treatment event (examples include noncompliance, a clinical event, or death). We identify natural mediation effects for the entire study population and for…
Causal Inference with Hidden Mediators
Proximal causal inference was recently proposed as a framework to identify causal effects from observational data in the presence of hidden confounders for which proxies are available. In this paper, we extend the proxim…
Causal InferenceA Fast Bootstrap Algorithm for Causal Inference with Large Data
Estimating causal effects from large experimental and observational data has become increasingly prevalent in both industry and research. The bootstrap is an intuitive and powerful technique used to construct standard er…
Causal InferenceComputational EfficiencyDeepMed: Semiparametric Causal Mediation Analysis with Debiased Deep Learning
Causal mediation analysis can unpack the black box of causality and is therefore a powerful tool for disentangling causal pathways in biomedical and social sciences, and also for evaluating machine learning fairness. To …
Causal InferenceDeep LearningFairnessGeneral targeted machine learning for modern causal mediation analysis
Causal mediation analyses investigate the mechanisms through which causes exert their effects, and are therefore central to scientific progress. The literature on the non-parametric definition and identification of media…
Causal Inference