Nonparametric Feature Impact and Importance
Practitioners use feature importance to rank and eliminate weak predictors during model development in an effort to simplify models and improve generality. Unfortunately, they also routinely conflate such feature importance measures with feature impact, the isolated effect of an explanatory variable on the response variable. This can lead to real-world consequences when importance is inappropriately interpreted as impact for business or medical insight purposes. The dominant approach for computing importances is through interrogation of a fitted model, which works well for feature selection, but gives distorted measures of feature impact. The same method applied to the same data set can yield different feature importances, depending on the model, leading us to conclude that impact should be computed directly from the data. While there are nonparametric feature selection algorithms, they typically provide feature rankings, rather than measures of impact or importance. They also typically focus on single-variable associations with the response. In this paper, we give mathematical definitions of feature impact and importance, derived from partial dependence curves, that operate directly on the data. To assess quality, we show that features ranked by these definitions are competitive with existing feature selection techniques using three real data sets for predictive tasks.
Code (2)
Tasks
Feature Importancefeature selectionMethods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Nonparametric IPSS: Fast, flexible feature selection with false discovery control
Feature selection is a critical task in machine learning and statistics. However, existing feature selection methods either (i) rely on parametric methods such as linear or generalized linear models, (ii) lack theoretica…
Feature Importancefeature selectionNonparametric Part Transfer for Fine-grained Recognition
In the following paper, we present an approach for finegrained recognition based on a new part detection method. In particular, we propose a nonparametric label transfer technique which transfers part constellations from…
Fine-Grained Image ClassificationImage SegmentationSemantic SegmentationA general framework for inference on algorithm-agnostic variable importance
In many applications, it is of interest to assess the relative contribution of features (or subsets of features) toward the goal of predicting a response -- in other words, to gauge the variable importance of features. M…
validNonparametric variable importance using an augmented neural network with multi-task learning
In predictive modeling applications, it is often of interest to determine the relative contribution of subsets of features in explaining the variability of an outcome. It is useful to consider this variable importan…
Multi-Task LearningNonparametric Scene Parsing with Adaptive Feature Relevance and Semantic Context
This paper presents a nonparametric approach to semantic parsing using small patches and simple gradient, color and location features. We learn the relevance of individual feature channels at test time using a locally ad…
RetrievalScene ParsingSemantic Parsing