Predicting decision-making in the future: Human versus Machine
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have become remarkably successful in data prediction, and have even been used to predict future actions based on limited input. This raises the question: do these systems actually "understand" the event similar to humans? Here, we address this issue using videos taken from an accident situation in a driving simulation. In this situation, drivers had to choose between crashing into a suddenly-appeared obstacle or steering their car off a previously indicated cliff. We compared how well humans and a DNN predicted this decision as a function of time before the event. The DNN outperformed humans for early time-points, but had an equal performance for later time-points. Interestingly, spatio-temporal image manipulations and Grad-CAM visualizations uncovered some expected behavior, but also highlighted potential differences in temporal processing for the DNN.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
Decision MakingSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Who Goes First? Influences of Human-AI Workflow on Decision Making in Clinical Imaging
Details of the designs and mechanisms in support of human-AI collaboration must be considered in the real-world fielding of AI technologies. A critical aspect of interaction design for AI-assisted human decision making a…
Decision MakingDiagnosticUnderstanding Human Behaviors in Crowds by Imitating the Decision-Making Process
Crowd behavior understanding is crucial yet challenging across a wide range of applications, since crowd behavior is inherently determined by a sequential decision-making process based on various factors, such as the ped…
Collision AvoidanceDecision MakingImitation LearningSequential Decision MakingLearning signatures of decision making from many individuals playing the same game
Human behavior is incredibly complex and the factors that drive decision making--from instinct, to strategy, to biases between individuals--often vary over multiple timescales. In this paper, we design a predictive frame…
Decision MakingConformal Prediction and Human Decision Making
Methods to quantify uncertainty in predictions from arbitrary models are in demand in high-stakes domains like medicine and finance. Conformal prediction has emerged as a popular method for producing a set of predictions…
Conformal PredictionDecision MakingPredictionUncertainty QuantificationFacebook drives behavior of passive households in stock markets
Recent studies using data on social media and stock markets have mainly focused on predicting stock returns. Instead of predicting stock price movements, we examine the relation between Facebook data and investors' decis…
Decision Making