Minimizing Errors or Surprises?
Traditional finance and macroeconomic models usually assume people can form rational expectations or reach them via a learning path by minimizing prediction errors. The recent Reference Model Based Learning (RMBL) model provides a new perspective: It hypothesizes that people minimize surprises instead of errors. Following the spirit of Simon's "satisficing" criteria, RMBL predicts that they will minimize errors only when the prediction error exceeds a threshold. We conduct meta-analyses based on 18 Learning-to-Forecast Experiments (LtFEs; N=41,490). Our results from the horse race test consistently show that student participants minimize surprises instead of errors in the LtFEs. In contrast, the results based on the data from the Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF) show no evidence that they minimize surprises. Together, our results suggest that minimizing surprises by implementing RMBL may be the simple procedure people employ when navigating complexity in forecasting.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Methods 이 논문이 사용한 방법론
Similar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
A Surprising Thing: The Application of Machine Learning Ensembles and Signal Theory to Predict Earnings Surprises
Nonlinear classification models can predict future earnings surprises with a high accuracy by using pricing and earnings input data. Surprises of 15% or more can be predicted with 71% accuracy. These predictions can be u…
Feature EngineeringReasoning about unpredicted change and explicit time
Reasoning about unpredicted change consists in explaining observations by events; we propose here an approach for explaining time-stamped observations by surprises, which are simple events consisting in the change of the…
Ordered Surprises and Conditional Probability Systems
We study conditioning on null events, or surprises, and behaviorally characterize the Ordered Surprises (OS) representation of beliefs. For feasible events, our Decision Maker (DM) is Bayesian. For null events, our DM co…
Beyond Surprise: Improving Exploration Through Surprise Novelty
We present a new computing model for intrinsic rewards in reinforcement learning that addresses the limitations of existing surprise-driven explorations. The reward is the novelty of the surprise rather than the surprise…
Atari GamesRetrievalHow Does Monetary Policy Influence the U.S. Treasury Bond Yields, and What are the Implications for Portfolio Managers?
This paper investigates the impact of monetary policy surprises on U.S. Treasury bond yields and the implications for portfolio managers. Based on the supply and demand model, traditional economic theories suggest that F…