Some Options for Instantiation of Bipolar Argument Graphs with Deductive Arguments
Argument graphs provide an abstract representation of an argumentative situation. A bipolar argument graph is a directed graph where each node denotes an argument, and each arc denotes the influence of one argument on another. Here we assume that the influence is supporting, attacking, or ambiguous. In a bipolar argument graph, each argument is atomic and so it has no internal structure. Yet to better understand the nature of the individual arguments, and how they interact, it is important to consider their internal structure. To address this need, this paper presents a framework based on the use of logical arguments to instantiate bipolar argument graphs, and a set of possible constraints on instantiating arguments that take into account the internal structure of the arguments, and the types of relationship between arguments.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
ARCSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
A Methodology for Incompleteness-Tolerant and Modular Gradual Semantics for Argumentative Statement Graphs
Gradual semantics (GS) have demonstrated great potential in argumentation, in particular for deploying quantitative bipolar argumentation frameworks (QBAFs) in a number of real-world settings, from judgmental forecasting…
Modular Semantics and Characteristics for Bipolar Weighted Argumentation Graphs
This paper addresses the semantics of weighted argumentation graphs that are bipolar, i.e. contain both attacks and supports for arguments. It builds on previous work by Amgoud, Ben-Naim et. al. We study the various char…
AllInstantiations and Computational Aspects of Non-Flat Assumption-based Argumentation
Most existing computational tools for assumption-based argumentation (ABA) focus on so-called flat frameworks, disregarding the more general case. In this paper, we study an instantiation-based approach for reasoning in …
Bipolar Weighted Argumentation Graphs
This paper discusses the semantics of weighted argumentation graphs that are biplor, i.e. contain both attacks and support graphs. The work builds on previous work by Amgoud, Ben-Naim et. al., which presents and compares…
A Tutorial for Weighted Bipolar Argumentation with Continuous Dynamical Systems and the Java Library Attractor
Weighted bipolar argumentation frameworks allow modeling decision problems and online discussions by defining arguments and their relationships. The strength of arguments can be computed based on an initial weight and th…