Forecast Aggregation via Peer Prediction
Crowdsourcing enables the solicitation of forecasts on a variety of prediction tasks from distributed groups of people. How to aggregate the solicited forecasts, which may vary in quality, into an accurate final prediction remains a challenging yet critical question. Studies have found that weighing expert forecasts more in aggregation can improve the accuracy of the aggregated prediction. However, this approach usually requires access to the historical performance data of the forecasters, which are often not available. In this paper, we study the problem of aggregating forecasts without having historical performance data. We propose using peer prediction methods, a family of mechanisms initially designed to truthfully elicit private information in the absence of ground truth verification, to assess the expertise of forecasters, and then using this assessment to improve forecast aggregation. We evaluate our peer-prediction-aided aggregators on a diverse collection of 14 human forecast datasets. Compared with a variety of existing aggregators, our aggregators achieve a significant and consistent improvement on aggregation accuracy measured by the Brier score and the log score. Our results reveal the effectiveness of identifying experts to improve aggregation even without historical data.
Code (0)
등록된 구현이 없습니다.
Tasks
PredictionSimilar Papers 제목 키워드 기반
Probabilistic Forecast-based Portfolio Optimization of Electricity Demand at Low Aggregation Levels
In the effort to achieve carbon neutrality through a decentralized electricity market, accurate short-term load forecasting at low aggregation levels has become increasingly crucial for various market participants' strat…
Computational EfficiencyDensity EstimationLoad ForecastingPortfolio OptimizationUncertainty-Aware Knowledge Transformers for Peer-to-Peer Energy Trading with Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning
This paper presents a novel framework for Peer-to-Peer (P2P) energy trading that integrates uncertainty-aware prediction with multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL), addressing a critical gap in current literature. In…
Multi-agent Reinforcement LearningOnline Knowledge Distillation with Diverse Peers
Distillation is an effective knowledge-transfer technique that uses predicted distributions of a powerful teacher model as soft targets to train a less-parameterized student model. A pre-trained high capacity teacher, ho…
Knowledge DistillationTransfer LearningDeep Transfer Learning Based Peer Review Aggregation and Meta-review Generation for Scientific Articles
Peer review is the quality assessment of a manuscript by one or more peer experts. Papers are submitted by the authors to scientific venues, and these papers must be reviewed by peers or other authors. The meta-reviewers…
ArticlesReview GenerationTransfer LearningCombining Combined Forecasts: a Network Approach
This study investigates the practice of experts aggregating forecasts before informing a decision-maker. The significance of this subject extends to various contexts where experts inform their assessments to a decision-m…
Decision Making